Can You Claim Home Maintenance Expenses on Schedule J If You Rent? Understanding the $100 Deduction That Can Become a Bankruptcy Trustee Dispute

Published

Bankruptcy Schedule J showing a $100 monthly home maintenance expense deduction beside a rental apartment building and RENT house, illustrating whether renters can claim home maintenance expenses in Chapter 7 bankruptcy.

One of the more interesting issues that can arise when preparing bankruptcy schedules is whether a debtor who rents an apartment or house can claim an expense for home maintenance, repairs, and upkeep.

Schedule J, which is filed in both Chapter 7 and Chapter 13 bankruptcy cases, asks debtors to disclose their monthly living expenses. One of the expense categories is found at Section 4(c), entitled “Home maintenance, repair, and upkeep expenses.”

Recently, I encountered a situation in which a Chapter 7 trustee objected to a debtor claiming $100 per month for this expense. The trustee’s apparent position was that because the debtor rented an apartment rather than owned a home, the debtor should not be entitled to claim anything in this category.

I think that position raises a legitimate question: Does renting a home automatically eliminate the possibility of having home maintenance expenses?

In my opinion, the answer is no.

There is nothing inherently unreasonable about a tenant incurring expenses to maintain, repair, and keep up the place where he or she lives. While a landlord is generally responsible for certain structural and major maintenance obligations, that does not mean the tenant never incurs expenses associated with maintaining the rental property.

The more important question is not whether the debtor owns or rents the property. It is whether the debtor actually incurs reasonable and necessary expenses that properly fall within this category.

Let’s take a closer look.

1. Does Schedule J Require You to Own Your Home?

I believe the wording of Schedule J is important.

Look at Section 4 of Official Form 106J. It is entitled:

“The rental or home ownership expenses for your residence.”

The form expressly recognizes that a debtor may either rent or own the residence. It then breaks out several additional expenses:

  • 4(a): Real estate taxes.
  • 4(b): Property, homeowner’s, or renter’s insurance.
  • 4(c): Home maintenance, repair, and upkeep expenses.
  • 4(d): Homeowner’s association or condominium dues.

Notice that the form does not say that Section 4(c) is available only to homeowners.

In fact, the form uses the broader phrase “your residence.” It does not limit the expense category to someone who owns the property.

I think this is an important distinction. If the bankruptcy form intended to restrict this expense to homeowners, it could easily have said so.

Instead, it separately identifies rental and homeownership expenses and then identifies maintenance, repair, and upkeep as an additional category.

That is a reasonable basis for arguing that a tenant can incur expenses that belong in Section 4(c).

See Official Bankruptcy Form 106J – Schedule J. United States Courts+1

2. What Types of Expenses Can a Renter Claim?

Of course, just because a person rents an apartment does not mean that the person automatically qualifies for a $100 monthly maintenance deduction.

There needs to be a legitimate expense.

The question becomes what types of expenses a tenant might reasonably incur in maintaining the property.

Here are some examples.

Minor repairs and maintenance

Depending on the terms of the lease, a tenant might be responsible for certain minor repairs or maintenance items, including:

  • Replacing light bulbs and batteries in smoke detectors.
  • Replacing furnace filters or air conditioning filters.
  • Minor plumbing repairs that the lease makes the tenant responsible for.
  • Replacing damaged screens or window coverings.
  • Minor repairs to doors, locks, and other fixtures.
  • Repairing or replacing items that the tenant is responsible for maintaining under the rental agreement.

A tenant may not be responsible for these items in every rental arrangement. However, when the tenant actually bears these expenses, they should not automatically be excluded simply because the tenant does not own the property.

Yard maintenance and exterior upkeep

A person renting a house may also have responsibilities that someone renting an apartment does not.

For example:

  • Lawn mowing and lawn maintenance.
  • Snow removal and ice treatment.
  • Maintaining landscaping.
  • Minor repairs to fencing.
  • Maintaining a deck or patio.
  • Purchasing supplies necessary to maintain the exterior of the rental property.

Some landlords include these services in the rent. Others require the tenant to handle them.

If the tenant is contractually responsible for these expenses, they may be legitimate maintenance expenses.

Pest control and preventative maintenance

Another possible category involves expenses associated with keeping the residence in good condition.

Examples might include:

  • Tenant-paid pest control.
  • Preventative maintenance supplies.
  • Caulking and weatherproofing.
  • Minor maintenance of appliances supplied by the landlord, where the lease makes the tenant responsible.
  • Supplies used to prevent damage to the rental property.

Again, these expenses must actually be incurred by the tenant.

Other household upkeep expenses

There may also be miscellaneous expenses associated with maintaining the residence.

For example, a tenant might have to purchase certain replacement parts, hardware, or maintenance supplies.

However, I would distinguish these expenses from ordinary household purchases.

Cleaning products, paper towels, laundry detergent, and similar items are generally ordinary household expenses, not necessarily home maintenance expenses. They should not simply be placed in Section 4(c) because they relate to maintaining a clean home.

Likewise, furniture, decorations, televisions, and other personal purchases do not become maintenance expenses merely because they are used in the residence.

The distinction is between maintaining the physical residence and purchasing ordinary consumer goods.

3. Isn’t the Landlord Responsible for Maintaining a Rental Property?

This is probably the strongest argument the Chapter 7 trustee could make.

Generally speaking, a landlord has responsibility for maintaining the rental property and keeping it in a condition suitable for occupancy. Michigan law also imposes certain obligations on residential landlords.

Under MCL 554.139, landlords have statutory obligations involving the premises and common areas, including keeping the premises fit for the use intended and keeping common areas fit and in reasonable repair.

Consequently, a tenant renting an apartment generally does not have the same maintenance responsibilities as someone who owns a house.

For example, if the furnace breaks down, the roof leaks, the plumbing fails, or the building needs major repairs, those expenses ordinarily belong to the landlord rather than the tenant.

But this does not mean that tenants never incur maintenance expenses.

There is a difference between a landlord’s responsibility for major repairs and a tenant’s responsibility for ordinary upkeep.

Consider someone renting a single-family house. The lease might require the tenant to mow the lawn, remove snow, maintain landscaping, replace furnace filters, and handle certain minor repairs.

Those are real expenses.

Similarly, someone renting an apartment might have certain maintenance responsibilities that are not covered by the landlord.

I would therefore argue that the fact that someone rents rather than owns a residence is relevant to determining whether the expense is reasonable, but it should not automatically disqualify the expense.

4. Is the $100 Monthly Expense Reasonable?

This is where I think the actual facts become important.

A debtor claiming $100 per month is claiming $1,200 annually.

That is not an insignificant amount, and a Chapter 7 trustee is entitled to question whether the expense is legitimate.

But I would not automatically agree that the expense should be disallowed.

For example, consider two different situations.

Example One: Apartment Tenant

A debtor rents an apartment for $1,200 per month.

The landlord handles all major repairs, landscaping, snow removal, plumbing, heating, and maintenance.

The tenant has no contractual responsibility for any repairs or upkeep.

In this situation, I would have difficulty defending a $100 monthly expense under Section 4(c).

There may be occasional incidental expenses, but simply putting $100 on Schedule J without an explanation would be questionable.

Example Two: Tenant Renting a Single-Family House

A debtor rents a house and pays $1,500 per month.

Under the lease, the tenant is responsible for lawn maintenance, snow removal, furnace filters, minor repairs, and certain preventative maintenance.

The tenant spends approximately $1,200 annually on these items.

In this situation, I think the $100 monthly expense is entirely reasonable.

The debtor is actually incurring the expenses, and the fact that the debtor does not hold title to the property should not change that analysis.

There is also a third situation worth considering.

A tenant might not spend exactly $100 every month. Perhaps the tenant spends $30 one month, nothing the next month, and $200 the following month.

That does not necessarily mean the expense is improper.

Schedule J asks the debtor to estimate ongoing monthly expenses as of the bankruptcy filing date. It is reasonable to use an appropriate monthly average for recurring or reasonably anticipated maintenance expenses rather than requiring the debtor to spend precisely $100 every calendar month.

However, there should be a reasonable factual basis for that average. United States Courts+1

5. What Evidence Should Be Provided to the Bankruptcy Trustee?

If a Chapter 7 trustee objects to a maintenance expense claimed by a tenant, I think the best approach is to provide an explanation rather than simply arguing that renters are entitled to claim the expense.

Some useful documentation might include:

  1. A copy of the rental agreement showing the tenant’s maintenance responsibilities.
  2. Receipts for maintenance supplies and repairs.
  3. Receipts for lawn care, snow removal, or pest control.
  4. A reasonable estimate of recurring annual maintenance expenses.
  5. An explanation of which expenses are the tenant’s responsibility rather than the landlord’s.

If the debtor has actually incurred these expenses, there should be no reason to avoid explaining them.

On the other hand, if the debtor cannot identify any actual or reasonably anticipated maintenance expenses, I would be reluctant to defend the deduction.

The bankruptcy schedules must be accurate. We should not claim expenses simply because a category appears on a bankruptcy form.

6. Does Schedule J Have Anything to Do With the Chapter 7 Means Test?

There is another distinction worth mentioning.

Schedule J and the Chapter 7 means test are not the same thing.

The Chapter 7 means test is governed by 11 U.S.C. § 707(b)(2). It uses a combination of IRS National and Local Standards and certain actual expenses to determine whether a presumption of abuse arises.

Schedule J, on the other hand, provides a picture of the debtor’s actual ongoing household expenses.

Just because an expense appears on Schedule J does not mean that the same amount is automatically allowed as a deduction under the means test.

Likewise, the fact that a debtor claims $100 for home maintenance on Schedule J does not automatically establish that the debtor is entitled to a $100 deduction under the means test.

These are separate inquiries, and they should not be confused.

The means test has its own rules governing allowable expenses. U.S. Code+1

7. My Opinion: Renting Should Not Automatically Disqualify the Expense

Having practiced bankruptcy law for approximately 35 years, I have learned that bankruptcy trustees sometimes take positions that deserve closer examination.

I understand why a trustee might question a $100 monthly home maintenance expense when the debtor rents an apartment.

After all, the landlord generally has responsibility for major repairs, and many apartment tenants have very few maintenance responsibilities.

But I would disagree with a blanket rule that a renter cannot claim anything under Section 4(c).

The language of Schedule J does not impose an ownership requirement. It specifically addresses both rental and homeownership expenses and then separately identifies home maintenance, repair, and upkeep.

In my opinion, the proper analysis should be based on the actual circumstances.

Does the tenant have maintenance responsibilities under the lease? Does the tenant actually spend money maintaining the residence? Are the expenses reasonable? Are they recurring or reasonably anticipated? Are they properly classified as maintenance rather than ordinary household purchases?

Those are the questions that should determine whether the expense is appropriate.

I would be much more comfortable defending a $100 monthly expense for someone renting a single-family house who is responsible for lawn care, snow removal, and minor maintenance than I would for someone renting an apartment where the landlord provides all maintenance services.

The bottom line is that renting a home does not necessarily mean that you have no home maintenance expenses. But you should be prepared to explain and substantiate whatever amount you claim.

Need help with a Chapter 7 bankruptcy?

At the Law Offices of Walter Metzen, I concentrate exclusively on bankruptcy law. I have represented more than 25,000 people in bankruptcy matters throughout my career.

If you are considering filing Chapter 7 bankruptcy in Michigan, or have questions about the expenses you can legitimately claim on your bankruptcy schedules, I invite you to contact my office.

Law Offices of Walter Metzen

Phone: 313-962-4656

Website: DetroitBankruptcyLawyer.com

This article is for general educational purposes and is not a substitute for legal advice concerning your particular circumstances.

Walter Metzen

For over 35 years, Michigan Bankruptcy Lawyer Walter A. Metzen has represented thousands of consumers needing a fresh financial start. All bankruptcy attorneys at our office pride ourselves in giving personal attention to our clients. Our bankruptcy law firm primarily represents individuals and small businesses, not large corporations. We believe that bankruptcy is an honest solution to debt problems and offer free initial consultations to determine if we can help you.

Get Started

Filing Personal Bankruptcy Is About Starting Over

Call 313-962-4656 or email us to schedule a free initial consultation!

Why Are More People Filing Bankruptcy Since the Pandemic? What’s Happening to Michigan Families?

Can I Keep My 401(k) If I File Bankruptcy?

Why Did My Credit Card Company Sue Me So Quickly After I Stopped Making Payments?